Earplugs: Difference between revisions

No edit summary
Line 321: Line 321:
<h3> My recommendations </h3>
<h3> My recommendations </h3>


<table border=1 align="right" cellpadding=1>
<tr><td width=180>
<center>'''Not recommended: SilentEar silicone earplugs'''</center>
<center>[[Image:IJ 14.jpg]]</center>
As part of my quest for good earplugs, I also gave the silicone [http://earplugstore.stores.yahoo.net/silnatrubear.html SilentEar]
plugs a try.  The same site which sold me the assortment of foam plugs
recommends the silicone plugs highly.  Plus, they're reuseable, so
they're more of a one-time investment.  For less than $20 for the size
assortment, I figured it'd be worth a try.
As I'd expected, I needed the medium size in my left ear, and the
large in my right.  They were a little strange to insert, since they
have a slick surface compared to foam plugs, and they need to slide
into place.
A quick test fitting at home seemed to show promise, so I left them
in and got my helmet on to go for a test ride.  I had brought my old
trusty 3M 1100s with me, just in case.  Almost as soon as I got my
helmet on, the right plug developed a "leak" and I could hear at full
volume again from that ear.  I pulled off my helmet, and seated the
plug again.  I got the helmet on without incident, but before I'd even
started moving, the plug was "leaking" again.  I stopped 500 yards down
the road and swapped to the 1100s.
It seemed that even the slightest jaw movement would dislodge one
or both of the plugs.  When they were seated and sealed, they seemed
promising.  Unfortunately, they unseated again so quickly that there
was really no point in pursuing them.
Based on my own experience, I do not recommend these plugs.  They
might be worth a try, but it seems like the chance that they'll happen
to fit you exactly right probably isn't worth the price of admission:
for about the same price, you can get a box of 200 pairs of good foam
earplugs which are much more likely to fit and seal every time.
</td></tr>
</table>
Any of the high-scoring plugs in this comparison seem like a fine
Any of the high-scoring plugs in this comparison seem like a fine
choice.  I really like the Howard Leight packaging, which makes it easy
choice.  I really like the Howard Leight packaging, which makes it easy
Line 436: Line 396:
<hr>
<hr>
Copyright 2005-2006 by Ian Johnston.
Copyright 2005-2006 by Ian Johnston.
====SilentEar silicone earplugs====
[[Image:IJ 14.jpg]]
As part of my quest for good earplugs, I also gave the silicone [http://earplugstore.stores.yahoo.net/silnatrubear.html SilentEar]
plugs a try.  The same site which sold me the assortment of foam plugs
recommends the silicone plugs highly.  Plus, they're reuseable, so
they're more of a one-time investment.  For less than $20 for the size
assortment, I figured it'd be worth a try.
As I'd expected, I needed the medium size in my left ear, and the
large in my right.  They were a little strange to insert, since they
have a slick surface compared to foam plugs, and they need to slide
into place.
A quick test fitting at home seemed to show promise, so I left them
in and got my helmet on to go for a test ride.  I had brought my old
trusty 3M 1100s with me, just in case.  Almost as soon as I got my
helmet on, the right plug developed a "leak" and I could hear at full
volume again from that ear.  I pulled off my helmet, and seated the
plug again.  I got the helmet on without incident, but before I'd even
started moving, the plug was "leaking" again.  I stopped 500 yards down
the road and swapped to the 1100s.
It seemed that even the slightest jaw movement would dislodge one
or both of the plugs.  When they were seated and sealed, they seemed
promising.  Unfortunately, they unseated again so quickly that there
was really no point in pursuing them.
Based on my own experience, I do not recommend these plugs.  They
might be worth a try, but it seems like the chance that they'll happen
to fit you exactly right probably isn't worth the price of admission:
for about the same price, you can get a box of 200 pairs of good foam
earplugs which are much more likely to fit and seal every time.